Measuring Email Campaign Success: Key Metrics and Strategies

Email marketing remains one of the most effective ways to reach and engage your audience, but how do you know if your efforts are paying off? Understanding and measuring the success of your email campaigns is crucial for refining your strategy and achieving your marketing goals. Let’s explore the key metrics you should track and some strategies to ensure your email campaigns are on the right path to success.

1. Open Rate: The First Step in Engagement

The open rate is one of the first indicators of how well your email campaign is performing. It measures the percentage of recipients who open your email compared to the total number of emails delivered. A higher open rate typically indicates that your subject line and sender name resonated with your audience – and that your previous content was also of interest.

What to look for: Average open rates can vary by industry, but generally, a good open rate falls between 10% to 25%. If your open rates are low, consider experimenting with different subject lines or sending times.

When not to use: If your subject line is so informative that it allows your audience to filter the message based on relevance, then open rates may not be a good metric. For example, if you are hosting an event or webinar and put the date in the subject line, it may simply be ignored because the recipient already has plans on that day.

2. Click-Through Rate (CTR): Gauging Interest and Engagement

The click-through rate measures the percentage of recipients who clicked on one or more links within your email. This metric helps you understand how compelling your content and calls to action (CTAs) are.

What to look for: Average CTRs typically range from 2% to 10%, depending on your industry and audience. A low CTR may indicate that your content isn’t engaging enough or that your CTA needs to be more prominent or appealing.

When not to use: When you put content in an email, that is not intended to be clicked, don’t expect high click rates. Mobile coupons and save-the-date emails can be good examples; however, even those emails can be thought out to drive traffic beyond the email itself.

3. Conversion Rate: From Interest to Action

The conversion rate takes things a step further by measuring the percentage of recipients who completed a desired action after clicking through your email, such as making a purchase, signing up for a webinar, or downloading a resource. This metric directly ties to your email campaign’s goals.

What to look for: Conversion rates vary widely, but a rate of around 1% to 3% is often considered good. To improve conversions, ensure your landing pages are aligned with your email content and provide a seamless user experience.

How to track conversions: Use utm codes and other pass-through variables in your email links to identify (1) email as the traffic source and (2) the specific campaign as the content strategy. Unique landing pages with source-specific lead forms or unique deals are also common for less tech-savvy emailers.

Get started with iLoyal Email Studio

Plans that flex to your needs and budget. Do it yourself or ask iLoyal for help with templates, graphics, list management, and more.

or call us at

888-352-9889

4. Bounce Rate: Understanding Deliverability Issues

The bounce rate measures the percentage of emails that were not successfully delivered to recipients’ inboxes. There are two types of bounces: soft bounces (temporary issues, like a full inbox) and hard bounces (permanent issues, such as an invalid email address). Monitoring your bounce rate is essential for maintaining a healthy email list. Did you know the iLoyal Email Studio has one of the highest deliverability rates in the email app industry?

What to look for: Aim for a bounce rate below 1%. A high bounce rate (over 2%) can negatively impact your sender reputation and future deliverability. Regularly clean your email list to remove invalid addresses and anyone that has disengaged (not opened for 12-18 months).

How to clean your list before upload: iLoyal uses ZeroBounce to scrub client lists. We will do this for you so you can take advantage of the bulk rate pricing we receive as a heavy user of this service.

5. Unsubscribe Rate: Gauging Audience Satisfaction

The unsubscribe rate tracks the percentage of recipients who opt out of your email list after receiving a campaign. A high unsubscribe rate may signal that your audience is dissatisfied with your content or that they are receiving emails too frequently.

What to look for: An unsubscribe rate of less than 0.5% is generally considered acceptable. If you notice a spike in unsubscribes, consider surveying your audience to understand their preferences and adjust your strategy accordingly.

Get started with iLoyal Email Studio

Plans that flex to your needs and budget. Do it yourself or ask iLoyal for help with templates, graphics, list management, and more.

or call us at

888-352-9889

6. Engagement Over Time: Tracking Trends and Patterns

Looking at your metrics over time allows you to identify trends and patterns in your audience’s behavior. For example, are open rates declining over several campaigns? Is there a particular day of the week when engagement peaks? Analyzing historical data helps you make informed decisions for future campaigns.

What to look for: Use A/B testing to experiment with different subject lines, content, and sending times to optimize your campaigns based on historical performance. Regularly review your metrics to adjust your strategy and stay aligned with your audience’s preferences.

Measuring the success of your email campaigns involves tracking several key metrics that offer insight into your audience’s engagement and satisfaction. By paying attention to open rates, click-through rates, conversion rates, bounce rates, unsubscribe rates, and long-term engagement trends, you can refine your email marketing strategy and maximize your results. Continuous evaluation will ensure your campaigns remain effective and aligned with your business goals.

Stop fumbling around with email marketing.

Get the email marketing app with in-house access to design and data support.

Save time and money engaging on social media.

Streamline the way you manage social media. No upgrades required to get all the features.

Easy ways to get started with iLoyal

Start a Free App Trial
Book a Discovery Call
Use the Plan Builder

Just want the apps?

Sign up for a free trial by clicking the link for your choice of apps below. Upgrade to a paid plan when you are ready to start sending.

Email Studio: Free until contacts are added
Social Genius: Unlimited 14-day Trial
iLoyal SMS: Free until number is provisioned

Let's Chat!

Tell us what you want to accomplish with your marketing and we’ll connect you with the apps and team that fit you like a glove – even if it’s not iLoyal! Stop spending time searching and let experts guide you toward a marketing tech solution and great service experience.

Call during business hours @ 888-352-9889

Customize Your Service Plan

Choose marketing app licenses and service levels to customize a plan from nearly everything iLoyal offers – from email design support and content development to social posting and website design.

Questions? Contact us for a free consultation with our team of experts.

Call iLoyal at 888-352-9889 for a custom quote.

iLoyal Email Studio

Grow sales and create loyalty with an email marketing app packed with features and with access to experts in design and data.

We create love and loyalty.

Attract customers. Understand the market. Ace the customer experience. Drive sales.

We deliver the powerful technology you need to build customer relationships and stay top of mind with your audience. From branding and website design, from content ideation to campaign deployment, our caring experts are here to support you every step of the way.

Engage to Succeed

Get marketing ideas, keep up with best practices, be the first to know about tech updates, and more.