LinkedIn
Facebook
Twitter
Reddit
Tumblr
Email
Print
10 Really Bad Email Campaign Mistakes and What We Can Learn from Them
Email campaigns are a powerful tool to engage with customers, generate leads, and drive sales. However, not all email campaigns hit the mark. In fact, some of them fall flat—often in a big way. From poorly executed designs to confusing messaging and downright cringey content, bad email campaigns can damage your brand’s reputation or alienate your audience. Let’s dive into 10 examples of bad email campaigns and uncover what went wrong, so you can avoid making the same mistakes.
1. The Overload of Information
Sometimes, more is less. In one email campaign, a company crammed every single detail about their product launch into one email. The result? An overwhelming wall of text that made subscribers lose interest fast.
Lesson Learned: Keep your emails concise. Focus on a single, clear message with easy-to-read content that guides the reader toward an action.
2. The "Buy or Die" Approach
Aggressive sales tactics rarely work, but some email campaigns still resort to the hard sell. One email from a retailer had the subject line: “Last Chance or You’ll Miss Out Forever!” which ended up creating more anxiety than urgency.
Lesson Learned: Instead of pressuring your audience with scare tactics, build trust through value and relevance. Highlight benefits, not fear.
Get started with iLoyal Email Studio
Plans that flex to your needs and budget. Do it yourself or ask iLoyal for help with templates, graphics, list management, and more.
or call us at
3. The Design Disaster
There’s bad design, and then there’s “we forgot how colors work.” A company sent out an email with clashing neon backgrounds and unreadable font colors, making it impossible to follow along. People deleted it immediately.
Lesson Learned: Good design is crucial. Ensure your email is visually appealing with easy-to-read fonts, contrasting colors, and a layout that guides the reader through the content effortlessly.
4. The Personalization Fail
Personalization is a great way to connect with your audience—unless you get it wrong. A famous mishap occurred when an email started with, “Hi [FIRSTNAME], do you want the best deal?” This error turned a potentially engaging email into a joke.
Lesson Learned: Always double-check your data and make sure your personalization tokens are correctly set up before hitting send.
5. The Broken Link
Imagine receiving a promotional email offering a 50% discount, but the link to claim the offer doesn’t work. That’s what happened with a well-known brand’s campaign, leading to frustration and lost sales.
Lesson Learned: Test all links and CTAs before sending an email campaign. Even one broken link can severely impact your results and damage credibility.
6. The “I’m Not Interested” Campaign
An online streaming service sent an email to users promoting documentaries… even though the users had previously shown interest only in comedies. The mismatch led to high unsubscribe rates.
Lesson Learned: Segment your audience and send content that aligns with their preferences. Irrelevant content drives people away faster than you think.
7. The Too-Frequent Follow-Up
A company that sent three follow-up emails in one day to remind people about their webinar found themselves unsubscribed en masse. The frequency was too much, and the messaging became annoying.
Lesson Learned: Space out your emails. Respect your audience’s time, and don’t flood their inbox with repetitive content.
Get started with iLoyal Email Studio
Plans that flex to your needs and budget. Do it yourself or ask iLoyal for help with templates, graphics, list management, and more.
or call us at
8. The Unclear Call-to-Action
A poorly executed email from a retailer provided tons of information, but no clear direction. The lack of a specific call-to-action (CTA) left customers confused and unsure of what to do next.
Lesson Learned: Your email should have a clear CTA that stands out. Whether it’s a button or a bold link, make sure your audience knows exactly what action to take next.
9. The “Oops, Wrong Audience” Campaign
An email offering senior discounts went out to an entire mailing list, including younger audiences who had no interest in the deal. The brand received backlash for not targeting their promotion correctly.
Lesson Learned: Target the right audience. Use segmentation to ensure that the content of your email is relevant to the people receiving it.
10. The No-Reply Nightmare
Another common failure in email campaigns is sending emails from a “no-reply” address. A travel company sent out a survey to gauge customer satisfaction but did so from a no-reply email address, making it impossible for customers to engage directly.
Lesson Learned: If you want engagement, make it easy for people to respond. Don’t use no-reply email addresses; instead, encourage two-way communication to foster a stronger connection with your audience.
Conclusion
Not all email campaigns are created equal. By learning from these cringe-worthy mistakes, you can create email campaigns that resonate with your audience, provide value, and drive results. Keep your design clean, personalize your content correctly, and always test before hitting send. In doing so, you’ll avoid becoming an example of what not to do in email marketing.
Get started with iLoyal Email Studio
Plans that flex to your needs and budget. Do it yourself or ask iLoyal for help with templates, graphics, list management, and more.
or call us at
LinkedIn
Facebook
Twitter
Reddit
Tumblr
Email
Print
Popular Posts
- How Well-Designed Graphics Can Enhance Your Marketing Efforts and Attract Customersby iLoyal
- Getting to Know Your Customers on a Budget: Tips and Tricks for Conducting Cost-Effective Customer Experience Researchby iLoyal
- The Importance of Mapping Out Your Customer Experience Journey: How to Improve Customer Satisfactionby iLoyal
- The Power of Word-of-Mouth Marketing: How to Effectively Use Email to Generate Client Referralsby iLoyal
- The Importance of Aligning Your Email and Social Media Content Strategyby iLoyal
Get the email marketing app with in-house access to design and data support.
Streamline the way you manage social media. No upgrades required to get all the features.
Easy ways to get started with iLoyal
- Start a Free App Trial
- Book a Discovery Call
- Use the Plan Builder

Just want the apps?
Sign up for a free trial by clicking the link for your choice of apps below. Upgrade to a paid plan when you are ready to start sending.
Email Studio: Free until contacts are added
Social Genius: Unlimited 14-day Trial
iLoyal SMS: Free until number is provisioned

Let's Chat!
Tell us what you want to accomplish with your marketing and we’ll connect you with the apps and team that fit you like a glove – even if it’s not iLoyal! Stop spending time searching and let experts guide you toward a marketing tech solution and great service experience.
Call during business hours @ 888-352-9889


Customize Your Service Plan
Choose marketing app licenses and service levels to customize a plan from nearly everything iLoyal offers – from email design support and content development to social posting and website design.
Questions? Contact us for a free consultation with our team of experts.
Call iLoyal at 888-352-9889 for a custom quote.
iLoyal Email Studio
Grow sales and create loyalty with an email marketing app packed with features and with access to experts in design and data.
We create love and loyalty.
Attract customers. Understand the market. Ace the customer experience. Drive sales.
We deliver the powerful technology you need to build customer relationships and stay top of mind with your audience. From branding and website design, from content ideation to campaign deployment, our caring experts are here to support you every step of the way.
Engage to Succeed
Get marketing ideas, keep up with best practices, be the first to know about tech updates, and more.

© iLoyal, Inc. 1999-2023. All rights reserved. | Privacy Center | Terms & Conditions